City of Dis
Work in progress / feasibility draft

The Point Nemo Apology Expedition

A proposal of unusual nautical, sculptural and cultic seriousness: sail beyond the ordinary reach of civilisation to Point Nemo, lower a bronze image of Great Cthulhu into the abyss, and make formal amends for humanity's long and remarkably impolite bombardment of R'lyeh with obsolete spacecraft.

Very much a work in progress - not yet a fundraising offer
Work-in-progress notice: this is a feasibility document, not a final expedition specification or fundraising offer. The project is being developed in public. Vessel choice, statue dimensions and alloy, camera system, legal permissions, environmental safeguards, budget, supporter arrangements and expedition berths are all provisional. Some ideas described here may become firmer; others may be discarded entirely once specialists have had the opportunity to spoil the fun with facts.
The proposition

The Sleeper beneath the sea has grounds for complaint.

Point Nemo is the oceanic pole of inaccessibility, the place in the South Pacific furthest from land. The wider region has also become famous as a destination for controlled spacecraft re-entry. Lovecraft, meanwhile, placed R'lyeh in the same magnificently inconvenient part of the Pacific.

Pure coincidence, almost certainly. Yet Lovecraft readers will appreciate the awkward optics. For decades, humanity has selected this remote part of the South Pacific as a convenient place to dispose of obsolete spacecraft. Lovecraft, with characteristically bad manners towards future aerospace agencies, had already placed R'lyeh nearby. At some point one must concede that repeated orbital impacts begin to look less like disposal policy and more like artillery.

The proposal is therefore to charter a suitable expedition vessel, sail to Point Nemo, and conduct a fully documented ceremonial deployment of a purpose-built bronze statue of Cthulhu. It would be, in equal measure, Lovecraftian ritual theatre, expedition engineering, documentary film and a small act of cosmic diplomacy performed by people who know perfectly well that the cosmos has not asked for one.

To Great Cthulhu, High Priest of the Great Old Ones, dreaming in his house at R'lyeh: humanity wishes to acknowledge that the repeated arrival of obsolete spacecraft in your general neighbourhood may reasonably have been interpreted as hostile bombardment. No offence was intended. We therefore submit this bronze likeness in token of apology, and respectfully ask that, when the stars are right, our conduct be judged with whatever leniency is compatible with aeons of slumbering wrath. Receipt should not be construed as acceptance.
Map showing Point Nemo in relation to the nearest land
Point Nemo in the South Pacific. Map by Ada Cukminski, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Why here?

Lovecraft, inconveniently, put it rather close.

Map comparing fictional R'lyeh coordinates with Point Nemo
Published locations for fictional R'lyeh compared with Point Nemo. Image by Nojhan, via Wikimedia Commons. The map is illustrative, not navigational.

Lovecraft's fictional coordinates for R'lyeh, and later variants used by August Derleth, lie remarkably close to the real Pacific pole of inaccessibility. This geographical accident is far too good to waste.

Point Nemo has acquired a second modern mythology because remote South Pacific waters have been used as a target region for controlled re-entries. The expedition's conceit is therefore straightforward: where aerospace agencies see a convenient uninhabited region, Lovecraftians may reasonably see a long-running failure of interspecies diplomacy.

Important: this project does not assume that Lovecraft's fiction was prophetic, that Cthulhu exists, or that a bronze statue will avert the end of civilisation. Our working hypothesis is that Cthulhu does not exist, R'lyeh is fictional, and the expedition will encounter no supernatural opposition whatsoever. We nevertheless consider a formal apology prudent, on the off-chance that this hypothesis is mistaken.
The object

A bronze idol for the house that is not dead

MaterialSolid or massively thick bronze, selected for corrosion resistance, structural simplicity and the ability to remain remarkably unimpressed by several kilometres of seawater.
ScaleLarge enough to be unmistakably monumental, but constrained by vessel handling, crane capacity, transport and the shocking tendency of bronze to cost money by the tonne.
SculptureA commissioned interpretation rather than a generic monster. Sculptor Denise Dutton has already been consulted informally on the practical unpleasantness of making Cthulhu properly substantial.
Preliminary engineering drawing for the proposed Cthulhu statue, showing front, side and top views, dimensions and plinth details
Preliminary engineering-style concept study for the proposed bronze Cthulhu. Converted to PNG for broad browser compatibility. This is illustrative concept art rather than a finished fabrication drawing.

What began as a joke has, rather against its better judgement, started acquiring technical drawings.

The drawing at left is the best current visual anchor for the project: part sculptural proposal, part engineering conceit, and entirely in keeping with the notion that one might need to think seriously about lifting points for a Great Old One.

  • Overall dimensions, alloy choice, centre of gravity and handling loads would all need proper foundry and structural review.
  • Attachment points for cameras, lights, telemetry and the descent rig would need to be integrated cleanly into the final design.
  • If names are offered to major backers, the most likely solution is inscription on the plinth or on a dedicated bronze donor band worked into the base.
  • If the final legal advice rules out permanent placement, the same design can still serve for a ceremonial descent and recovery.
Design note: the engineering drawing is not presented as a literal fabrication package. It is a concept study to show the sort of monumental, abyss-capable statue the campaign has in mind.
Concept illustration of a bronze Cthulhu monument A stylised winged and tentacled bronze figure shown against dark water. CONCEPT ONLY - FORM, SCALE AND ALLOY TO BE ENGINEERED
Atmospheric concept artwork of the same general idea. The engineering drawing above is the more useful reference for campaign discussions.
The descent

The descent should be witnessed.

A deep-ocean camera package would transform the deployment from a ceremony on deck into an actual descent into darkness.

The preferred system would use pressure-rated cameras, high-output lighting, depth and temperature instrumentation, onboard recording and an acoustic beacon. A recoverable camera pod could detach after touchdown and return to the surface, preserving the footage even if the statue remains below.

True live HD video at abyssal depth would require more elaborate tether or fibre infrastructure. A more practical first design is continuous local 4K recording, with live depth and position telemetry relayed to the ship.

Two cameras would be ideal: one looking outward into the water column, and another looking back at the descending figure. At some point the Sun vanishes, the surface ceases to matter, and the only visible object is Cthulhu continuing down through his own pool of artificial light.

Proposed deep-ocean descent camera system A schematic showing the expedition ship, descending statue, camera module and abyssal seabed. Surface vessel Bronze statue Recoverable camera pod Abyssal seabed - final depth subject to selected site
Conceptual deployment only. The actual system would be designed around the vessel, sea state, target depth and recovery method.
Working budget

Approximately £350,000 - before the architects of R'lyeh submit extras

The original rough figure of £250,000 remains a plausible lower bound for a stripped-down expedition. Once a genuinely substantial bronze sculpture and properly engineered abyssal imaging package are included, a public target closer to £350,000 is more credible.

ItemWorking allowance
Expedition vessel, crew, fuel and operating days£140,000
Bronze Cthulhu - sculpture, material, foundry and finishing£95,000
Transport, lifting frame and deployment engineering£25,000
Deep-ocean camera, lights, telemetry and recovery system£25,000
Insurance, permits, maritime and environmental advice£15,000
Film, satellite communications and documentation£15,000
Travel, accommodation and expedition support£10,000
Contingency£25,000
Indicative target£350,000

These figures are deliberately provisional. Before crowdfunding, ship operators, foundries, insurers and marine contractors would be asked for indicative quotations. The project should not pretend that a number typed into a webpage has acquired the status of naval architecture.

Supporter recognition

A place in the bronze litany

A public campaign would need supporter recognition that is amusing, tangible and not too vulgar. One attractive upper-tier option is to allow major backers to have their names incorporated into the monument itself. Subject to the final sculpture design and foundry advice, this would most likely mean inscription on the plinth or on a dedicated bronze donor band wrapped around the base.

£25Corresponding Member of the Outer CircleDigital expedition roll and acknowledgement on the project page.
£100Friend of the Esoteric OrderPrinted certificate, expedition patch, and inclusion in the formal apology register carried aboard ship.
£500Keeper of the Cyclopean CoordinatesName entered in a physical ledger taken to Point Nemo and returned with the expedition record.
£2,500+Inscribed Patron of the DeepName inscribed on the statue base or donor band, space and final fabrication details permitting.
£20,000Witness to the DescentOne of a strictly limited number of expedition berths to Point Nemo, subject to the separate contractual, medical, insurance and vessel-operator arrangements described below.

If space, engineering or legal constraints make direct inscription on the exterior impractical, an alternative would be a sealed donor register capsule within the plinth together with a visible dedication band naming principal supporters.

Platform note: an expedition berth would not be offered as an ordinary GoFundMe reward if the platform rules in force at launch prohibit goods or services in return for donations. It would instead need to be arranged separately and transparently, with its own terms, safety requirements and accounting.

Witnesses to the descent

For six people, Point Nemo would not merely be a coordinate.

A small number of major supporters could join the expedition itself and be aboard when the bronze Cthulhu leaves the daylight world.

The provisional figure is £20,000 per person, with no more than six civilian expedition berths. That level is intentionally benchmarked against specialist expedition-cruise pricing rather than ordinary passenger travel: this is a long-range voyage to the most remote point in the world ocean, aboard a vessel selected primarily for seamanship, lifting capacity and operational competence rather than the quality of the cocktail menu.

A Witness to the Descent would be aboard for the passage to Point Nemo, the formal apology ceremony and the controlled deployment of the statue, with access to the expedition record and the live depth and position telemetry available on the vessel. If the deep-ocean camera system performs as intended, they would also witness the recorded or relayed descent as Cthulhu disappears through several kilometres of increasingly indifferent Pacific.

The berth would include accommodation and meals aboard during the expedition and participation in the deployment event. Travel to and from the embarkation port, personal insurance, visas, medical certification and other individual expenses would normally remain the traveller's responsibility unless a final expedition contract says otherwise.

Swimming at Point Nemo. If weather, sea state, water temperature, wildlife, vessel operations and the Master's judgement all permit, expedition members would be offered the opportunity to enter the water at Point Nemo under controlled conditions. This is emphatically an aspiration, not a promise. The Master would have an absolute veto, and nobody will be encouraged to prove their devotion to cosmic indifference by arguing with maritime safety.

There are very few places on Earth where a person can plausibly say that the nearest humans may be aboard a spacecraft passing overhead. We cannot promise that exact circumstance on the day. We can promise that anyone swimming at Point Nemo will be a quite unreasonable distance from the nearest pub.

Final availability would depend on vessel capacity, operator approval, insurance, medical requirements, applicable law and the expedition configuration. The £20,000 figure is therefore a planning figure, not yet an offer for sale.

A necessary complication

Even cultists require permits.

Deliberately placing or disposing of material at sea is regulated by international and national law. The London Convention and London Protocol exist precisely to control dumping at sea, and the Protocol adopts a particularly restrictive approach.

Accordingly, the permanent placement of the statue is an objective to be investigated, not something this draft promises. Before launch, the project would obtain proper advice on the flag state, departure state, applicable permits, environmental assessment and whether a permanent placement can lawfully be authorised.

If it cannot, the expedition still works: Cthulhu can be lowered ceremonially, filmed at depth, and recovered. There is something pleasingly appropriate about refusing to apologise for humanity throwing things into the Pacific by throwing another thing into the Pacific without permission.

A little actual science

If one must approach R'lyeh, one may as well take measurements.

A berth or instrument slot could be offered to an oceanographer, university group or citizen-science partner. Temperature, pressure, dissolved oxygen, water sampling, environmental DNA or other modest measurements could turn a theatrical expedition into an opportunity to collect useful observations from an exceptionally remote part of the world ocean.

The Lovecraftian objective gets the ship there. There is no reason the ship should return having learned nothing.

Proposed development path

From improbable proposal to possible expedition

Consultation
Circulate the concept among Lovecraftians and a small number of marine, engineering, legal and sculptural contacts. Find the obvious holes before committing money, metal or anyone's sea legs.
Feasibility
Obtain indicative vessel, sculpture, camera, insurance and legal costs. Decide whether £350,000 is sensible or merely optimistic with better typography.
Public campaign
Launch the GoFundMe with a short film, final concept art, transparent budget and a clear statement of what happens if the full target is not reached.
Expedition
Sail, document, deploy, measure, apologise, recover whatever must be recovered, and return before anyone notices the stars changing.
Status of the proposal

This is very much a work in progress.

This page describes an idea under active development, not a settled expedition plan, a booking page or a promise that every element described below will survive contact with engineering, maritime law, insurance and arithmetic.

The concept has already developed considerably through discussion with the Lovecraft community, including a more detailed HPLHS-facing draft. The intention is still the same: if this proceeds, it should have the texture of a genuine expedition - proper ship, proper engineering, proper documentation, proper bronze, proper coordinates and proper absurdity - rather than a floating novelty event.

I would particularly value thoughts on the statue design, ceremonial wording, environmental and legal constraints, realistic vessel and foundry costs, deep-ocean imaging, and contacts with suitable oceanographers, marine engineers, expedition operators, filmmakers or other specialists willing to contemplate the enterprise without immediately backing away from the room.

The current £350,000 budget, £20,000 expedition-berth figure, six-passenger limit, statue specification, deployment method, swimming proposal and even permanent seabed placement are all planning assumptions. Any of them may change as quotations, permits, environmental advice and vessel requirements become real. Nothing on this page should yet be treated as a commercial offer.

The more detailed Lovecraft-community working draft remains available at point-nemo-expedition-hplhs.html; this public-facing page will be revised as the project becomes less hypothetical and more expensive.

We should, if possible, contrive matters so that future archaeologists discovering the bronze object four kilometres beneath the Pacific are left with considerably more questions than answers.
Send comments to City of Dis
Provisional ceremonial form

The apology should be read as though someone, somewhere, may be listening.

The final text would be written only after consultation, but the tone ought to be more diplomatic note than comedy sketch. No winking, no theatrical chanting unless it earns its place, and no attempt to improve upon Lovecraft by burying the thing beneath fake archaism.

Ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn.

To the Sleeper of R'lyeh: we come neither as conquerors nor as worshippers, but as representatives of a species that has repeatedly dropped machinery into your vicinity and only lately considered that this might be construed as rude. We offer bronze in place of debris, apology in place of bombardment, and our respectful hope that this distinction will be remembered when remembrance becomes relevant.

The familiar R'lyehian line is included as a Lovecraftian flourish, not as an attempt to present Lovecraft's invented language as a recoverable grammar.

Sources and notes

Useful background

The International Maritime Organization describes the London Convention and London Protocol as the principal international instruments controlling dumping of wastes and other matter at sea. Under the Protocol, dumping is prohibited except for materials that may be considered under its specified exceptions. This draft therefore treats permanent placement as subject to legal and environmental review.

Map image: Ada Cukminski, "Location of Point Nemo in the South Pacific Ocean", CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons. R'lyeh comparison map: Nojhan, Wikimedia Commons. Preliminary statue engineering drawing supplied for the project discussion and converted to PNG for compatibility. See also the IMO pages on the London Convention and Protocol.

International Maritime Organization - London Convention and Protocol